How to Properly Size a Submersible Pump for Maximum Efficiency

Proper pump sizing is essential for achieving maximum efficiency and ensuring a long service life. Sizing a submersible pump involves determining the performance requirements—primarily flow rate and total dynamic head (TDH)—so that the chosen pump can meet these demands while operating near its Best Efficiency Point (BEP). Correctly sized wastewater pumps will consume less energy and experience less wear, whereas an improperly sized pump may suffer from frequent problems and inefficiencies, leading to increased maintenance and operational costs.

Determining Flow Rate and Head

1. Calculating Flow Rate

The first step in pump sizing is determining the required flow rate, which depends on the application:

Sump/Sewage Systems: Based on the number of fixtures and peak usage scenarios.
Industrial or Process Systems: Determined by system demands or regulatory requirements.
Municipal Applications: Defined by the capacity needed to manage stormwater, wastewater, or potable water.

Accurately estimating flow ensures the pump is neither underpowered nor oversized for the job.

2. Calculating Total Dynamic Head (TDH)

Total Dynamic Head (TDH) represents the total resistance a pump must overcome to move the fluid. It consists of:

Static Head: The vertical lift from the pump to the discharge point.
Friction Losses: Resistance caused by pipes, fittings, valves, and flow rate.

Static head is straightforward—it’s the elevation difference the pump needs to push the fluid. Friction loss, however, requires a detailed assessment of the piping system, including:

Pipe length and diameter
Flow velocity
Number and type of fittings (bends, valves, elbows)

Using standard friction loss charts or engineering formulas like the Hazen-Williams or Darcy-Weisbach equation, you can estimate pressure drop due to friction. For example:

40 GPM through 100 feet of 2-inch pipe results in about 2.6 feet of head loss.
Each 90° elbow in a 2-inch pipe adds friction equivalent to about 5 feet of straight pipe.

Summing static head and friction loss gives you the TDH your pump must generate at the required flow rate. Overestimating TDH by adding excessive safety margins can lead to selecting an oversized, inefficient pump. A reasonable contingency of 10-15% accounts for unknowns while keeping efficiency high.

Why Proper Sizing Matters (Efficiency and Longevity)

When a pump operates at or near its designed flow/head point, it runs cooler, smoother, and more efficiently. However, if the pump is throttled back too far or forced to run beyond its application range, serious issues arise:

Operating to the right of the curve (too much flow, not enough head) can cause motor overload and cavitation.
Operating far left (too much head, low flow) can lead to internal recirculation, excessive vibration, and heat buildup.

Studies show that pumps lose reliability when operating away from their BEP:

Failures double when a pump operates 20% below or 10% above its BEP flow.
A pump running at 60% efficiency consumes 40% more power than one at 85% efficiency.

For solids handling pumps running 24/7, efficiency losses can accumulate into tens of thousands of dollars in unnecessary energy costs. A well-sized pump not only saves energy but also reduces mechanical strain, extending its service life and lowering maintenance costs.

Sizing Tools and Best Practices

To correctly size a pump, utilize manufacturer pump curves and selection software. These tools allow you to:

Compare flow vs. head performance to ensure operation near BEP.
Check Net Positive Suction Head (NPSH) requirements to prevent cavitation.
Simulate different operating conditions for variable applications.

1. Using Pump Performance Curves

Pump performance curves plot flow vs. head and display efficiency zones. By plotting your calculated system TDH and flow rate onto a curve, you can:

Select a pump model that aligns with optimal efficiency.
Avoid selecting a pump that would operate in an unstable or inefficient region.

2. Utilizing Selection Software

Many manufacturers provide software to simplify pump selection. HOMA’s HOP.SEL tool allows engineers to input flow, head, and fluid properties to receive recommendations for the most suitable pump model. These tools:

Speed up selection by filtering pumps that don’t meet efficiency standards.
Help ensure proper motor sizing and NPSH compatibility.
Factor in variables like fluid viscosity, solids content, and system parameters.

3. Accounting for System Variability

If the pump must handle multiple operating points, consider:

Variable Speed/Frequency Drives (VSDs or VFDs): Allow pumps to adjust speed dynamically for changing conditions.
Duplex arrangements or Redundant Pumps: For applications with fluctuating demand, installing two smaller pumps can be more efficient than a single oversized unit.
Periodic Reevaluation: If system modifications occur (e.g., longer piping, new valves, fluid property changes), reassess TDH and flow to ensure the pump still meets operational needs.

4. Consulting with Experts

Pump sizing errors are costly, but avoidable. Consulting with HOMA’s application engineers or an experienced pump manufacturer ensures:

Your head calculations are correct.
The pump matches your system’s unique challenges.
You don’t miss critical details that could impact efficiency.

Looking for Submersible Pump Sizing Guidance?

Properly sizing a submersible pump is essential for efficiency, longevity, and cost savings. Following a methodical approach—calculating flow and TDH, using pump curves or software, and consulting experts—ensures the selected pump will function optimally for years to come. Investing the time to get pump sizing right at the outset prevents unnecessary energy waste, excessive maintenance, and premature failures.

For professional assistance with pump sizing, explore HOMA’s HOP.SEL selection tool or contact our team for expert guidance tailored to your specific needs.

Blog